MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Dear STKO team
I was modeling the soil-structure interaction with the half-space of soil without problemes. But I modeled the basement and the mesh of the soil dont let me advance in the analysis, please your help
I´ve attached the model and the mistake.
Best regards.
I was modeling the soil-structure interaction with the half-space of soil without problemes. But I modeled the basement and the mesh of the soil dont let me advance in the analysis, please your help
I´ve attached the model and the mistake.
Best regards.
- Attachments
-
- model.jpeg (111.14 KiB) Viewed 6232 times
-
- error.jpeg (48.02 KiB) Viewed 6232 times
-
- modelo with basement.rar
- (393.18 KiB) Downloaded 303 times
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
If you look at the error:
File "C:/Program Files/STKO\external_solvers\opensees\element_properties\brick_elements\SSPbrick.py", line 114, in writeTcl
raise Exception('Error: invalid type of element or number of nodes')
Your foundation is four node solid elements (tetra) while using brick elements (hexa). in the mesh, you need to mesh the foundation as hexa not tetra.
File "C:/Program Files/STKO\external_solvers\opensees\element_properties\brick_elements\SSPbrick.py", line 114, in writeTcl
raise Exception('Error: invalid type of element or number of nodes')
Your foundation is four node solid elements (tetra) while using brick elements (hexa). in the mesh, you need to mesh the foundation as hexa not tetra.
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Dear Lin Sun
Thanks for your recommendation, I get better meshing but I still have the same problem.
could you expand your answer?
I´ve attached the model and some pictures.
Thanks for your recommendation, I get better meshing but I still have the same problem.
could you expand your answer?
I´ve attached the model and some pictures.
- Attachments
-
- error 2.jpeg (36.68 KiB) Viewed 6212 times
-
- model 2.jpeg (44.16 KiB) Viewed 6212 times
-
- model1.jpeg (69.75 KiB) Viewed 6212 times
-
- modelo with basement better mesh.rar
- (409.66 KiB) Downloaded 337 times
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
You also assigned the sspbrick element property to some Edges of the soil domain. That's why it was keeping on giving the error.
Now it works, but you have another error due to the contact options. Please look at the webinar about the ASDContactElement for more information
Now it works, but you have another error due to the contact options. Please look at the webinar about the ASDContactElement for more information
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Dear STKO team
Thanks so much
I get to run the model and I had a razonable results. I´ve attached some pictures of the model.
Now, can I send you the model to some e-mail for your revition? because I want to start my final project with the model that I got made works.
In the same line maybe, Do you have any recommendation to how model the ML (silty - sand) soil with non-linearity? Wich ndMaterial can I use?
Best regards
Thanks so much
I get to run the model and I had a razonable results. I´ve attached some pictures of the model.
Now, can I send you the model to some e-mail for your revition? because I want to start my final project with the model that I got made works.
In the same line maybe, Do you have any recommendation to how model the ML (silty - sand) soil with non-linearity? Wich ndMaterial can I use?
Best regards
- Attachments
-
- modelo convergio.jpeg (62.07 KiB) Viewed 6100 times
-
- modelo convergio 2.jpeg (60.43 KiB) Viewed 6100 times
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Unfortunately we do not include this customized revision of private models in the research license. But you can share here your dubts about analysis results to that it we can check them one by one, and it will be useful for other users.Now, can I send you the model to some e-mail for your revition? because I want to start my final project with the model that I got made works.
Intermediate soils are hard to model. I don't know if there is a single material that can model it. I know there are the PM4Sand and the PM4Silt materials respectively, but they are only for 2D plane strain problemsIn the same line maybe, Do you have any recommendation to how model the ML (silty - sand) soil with non-linearity? Wich ndMaterial can I use?
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Dear STKO team
Thanks a lot. Now I have a problem with the transient analysis. I just modeled layers of the soil.
Please yout help
I´ve attached the mistake and the model.
Thanks a lot. Now I have a problem with the transient analysis. I just modeled layers of the soil.
Please yout help
I´ve attached the mistake and the model.
- Attachments
-
- mistake_transient_analysis.png (42.02 KiB) Viewed 6030 times
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
First I removed the eigen, because to make a fast test I partitioned the model in 6 partitions and eigen does not work in parallel.
Then I made a few changes in the constraint handler settings, test norms (in both analyses) and also the stiffness parameter in the embedding domain was too high
Then I made a few changes in the constraint handler settings, test norms (in both analyses) and also the stiffness parameter in the embedding domain was too high
Last edited by STKO Team on Wed Oct 12, 2022 7:05 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
Thanks a lot you are the best.
I dont understand what do you mean about " and also the stiffness parameter in the embedding domain was too high"
could expand your answer please?
I dont understand what do you mean about " and also the stiffness parameter in the embedding domain was too high"
could expand your answer please?
Re: MESH ERROR SOIL DOMAIN
If you read the documentation of the stiffness penalty parameter, it's suggested to make it few (2 or 3) order of magnitude larger than the Young's modulus of the Embedding Domain (Soil in your case).I dont understand what do you mean about " and also the stiffness parameter in the embedding domain was too high"
could expand your answer please?
It's based on the penalty apporach, so using a too high stiffness can make the convergence difficult